For the last few months, there has been hectic activity (including violence!) on the streets of Delhi as well as Hyderabad and many other cities of Andhra Pradesh. The issue at hand is whether the Telangana 'region' of AP should be made a separate state. Furious arguments are being raised on either side of the divide. In the end, as is the case with most things in India, it all ends up being about politics. Surprisingly however, most intellectuals in this case are found arguing against the creation of a separate state. Their main arguments can be summarized as follows:
1. Creation of a new state might lead to similar demands elsewhere and lead to 'Balkanization' of India.
2. Telangana is a land-locked and economically unviable state.
3. Hyderabad's economy will suffer if it goes to such a state.
4. Unnecessary paperwork and overhead will be involved in creating and maintaining a new state.
5. It divides the Telugu speaking people and areas.
However, having assessed the arguments of the Anti-Telangana forces, it seems to me that the main reason is only the last - that this divides the Telugu speaking regions. It goes against the 'linguistic states' philosophy that India followed originally. I for one, believe that a separate Telangana state MUST be carved out of AP! Here's why:
1. The fact of the matter is that the overwhelming majority of people from the Telangana region want a separate state. This has been the case for a few decades now, and has been reflected in the democratic choices those people have made. With this being the genuine wish of the majority, democratic ethos requires that their wish be respected within the constitution of India and it is only fair to grant them statehood. This applies to many other 'genuine burning demands of the people' elsewhere, especially Vidarbha in Maharashtra, Gorkhaland in West Bengal and Jammu and Ladakh in J&K. This is NOT 'Balkanization' of India as some argue, since, the people of Telangana are patriotic Indians in the end. They are not demanding a separate nationhood! What happened in the Balkans is a totally different story, where a nation broke down into multiple nations. Here, it will simply be a story of a nation federating itself further for the good.
2. By carving out a separate state out from a 'single language' state, the fundamental basis for 'linguistic chauvinism/regionalism' will be defeated, and this will send out a strong signal to every other 'linguistic' state. Linguistic chauvinism has always been one of India's banes, and this act could very well be a ground-breaking precedent to defeating that evil. We have seen a similar situation before in the sub-continent. Pakistan was carved out of India, arguing that different religions means different nations. But, by helping to carve out a Bengali-speaking Bangladesh out of it, India defeated the idea of religious nationalism. This applies not just to AP, but also Marathi-speaking Maharashtra.
3. India has created several so-called 'unviable' states before - the north-eastern states, for example. The problem is not the economic unviability as of the present, it is whether it is possible to make it viable in the future. Given Telangana's cultural and tourist potential, mineral wealth, etc, it is fairly clear that a viable state economy is possible. So this argument doesn't hold much water.
4. Reg the administrative overhead, one more state is no big deal for India. The United States, for example, has 50 states even though their population is only one-third of India's! The European Union is also similar. The Russian Federation is also a nice example of a large (the largest!) country being managed through multiple autonomous units. Anyways, AP as of now is too large for any government to run effectively. By 'shedding-off' Telangana, the new AP (coast + Rayalseema) can be a better administered state!
5. As far as Hyderabad is concerned, I agree it would be too expensive a loss economically for AP. Hence, I think it might be better to make it a Union Territory, and the shared capital of AP and the new Telangana, much like how Chandigarh is shared by Punjab and Haryana. The 'economic spoils' of Hyderabad can be shared by the two states. But this is easier said than done. Hyderabad is essentially 'surrounded' by Telangana (Rangareddy, Mahbubnagar and Nalgonda districts), and it will be tricky to implement such a solution.
6. Some people argue from a sentimental perspective about the 'unity of Telugu-speaking people'. But Telangana would only be made a separate state, not a separate country! And as per India's constitution, all states are equal and every Indian has a right to work/settle in any state. So this is no big deal either. Things are far worse for various other people elsewhere in the world. E.g, the Kurdish people are split between Iraq, Turkey and Iran, and don't have a unified nation to call their own!
Overall, I think India has too many 'elephantine' states, which are run very inefficiently. It might be wiser to split them up into smaller, more manageable, but viable states. But, this should be the case only where there is a real demand, and/or where it makes sense. E.g, UP continues to be a 'black-hole' state of India, and should seriously be split into two or three smaller states. Maharashtra, on the other hand, is a peculiar case. Even though it is India's richest state, the fact that statehood sentiments exist in Vidarbha only shows that the state government seems to have focused too much on Mumbai, Pune and the coast.
Hence, overall, I feel it is only wise to carve out a separate state of Telangana out of AP. But then again, as with most things in India, the decision ultimately is driven by political considerations, not logical/practical ones, even though a reputed former judge has been appointed to look into it!
Wednesday, March 17, 2010
Saturday, March 13, 2010
Prof PJ Returns!
Note: For those who saw the previous incarnation of this post titled 'Proj PJs/Bloopers and Awards', this is an 'anonymized and toned down' version of it. The reason is that a prof from IITM actually emailed me (!) and conveyed his/her displeasure at being quoted (typical 'misrepresented' and 'quoted out of context' kind of stuff that journalists hear often!), asked me to remove these quotes from the Web and advised me to 'respect' teachers, even quoting Bhagavad Gita slokas! Firstly, this means my post had become so famous! Secondly, I didn't realize by quoting profs commenting on other profs, I might put them in trouble! Thirdly, I didn't imagine people could take offence to trivial humorous stuff like this, but nevertheless I guess it is safer to strip out the names and publish only the quotes. I have also removed quotes of profs commenting on other profs, which is what prompted that email! I have classified them at the highest level (US/IITM/JEE Classes) for some context but still, some quotes might be have such an obvious context that the speaker can be identified easily. I can't help it!
Statutory Disclaimer: The following collection of funny quotes (PJs, bloopers, etc) are 'actual' words spoken by profs that I and my friends have seen over the years. But the intention is not to make fun of profs or put them in trouble, but to recollect and have a laugh at some intentional/unintentional funny statements.
US Profs:
"It is so funny that at the beginning of a class, whenever you turn to the board and turn back, there are more students everytime. But it just reverses towards to end of the class!"
(After explaining a new concept) "Is this clear to everyone? Any questions... what does this term mean... what statement is this... what class is this?!"
(After clarifying an ambiguous concept) "Oh, you guys don't feel happy about it? I feel so good about it!"
"You guys didn't understand it? Ok, let me keep explaining it in different ways till either you understand it or I!"
"All that botanists seem to do is sit and classify things!"
"Biology is only about memorizing, there's no figuring out. I mean, how does one figure out what phylum a plant is in?!"
"Schema matching is still a hard and open problem. If you get a good idea to solve it properly, tell me and we'll stop the course and start a company or something! Then, after we get rich, we can resume the class!"
"Mike Stonebraker once said that schema matching is AI-complete, i.e., it will never be solved by AI folks! And if it is solved, then it was not AI after all!"
"More than a decade ago, when I was at Palo Alto, a prof told me about a couple of bright students who had this new search engine based on their new PageRank algorithm. I thought it was a very nice idea and appreciated them! Darn, I should have instead asked if I could invest in their company right then! Then probably, I wouldn't still be here right now!"
"In a study on web search, it was found that the .edu domain is least frequently updated. So crawlers need not visit these webpages often!"
"There was this professor at Berkeley who forgot to set an exam paper. So he told the class, 'Sorry class, I forgot to set the paper for the exam today. So, here's the deal - those of who are very confident about this course and want an impromptu exam, stay back. Others can leave, I'll just generously give you a B.' Two-thirds of the class left, glad to have got a free B! Then he says to those who remained, 'Great! I'll just give you guys an A!'"
"If one cannot keep up, but cannot fall behind either, then the solution is to do a sloppy job!"
(When a student referred to 2002 as 'way back') "I object to your labeling of 2002 as 'way back'. It makes me feel very old!"
"I've realized that faculty life consists of nothing but emails, deadlines, meetings, and being late for those three!"
"Back when I joined grad school, people preferred primarily two fields - theory, which was considered 'manly', or AI, which was considered 'sexy'! Databases was considered even more boring than accounting!"
"If you want to graduate and leave at the earliest, but your advisor will not let you, then a very good option is to get married! Then, you can blame your 'family problems' for leaving grad school and he will no longer stop you!"
"A main lesson you learn in grad school is to speak very confidently about whatever you want to say, even if you are clueless about it!"
"In research, if you are going to tackle a complicated problem, you shouldn't solve it completely at one go and publish it in one paper. First, publish a good solution for a sub problem of it. Then, you will have lots of people trying to extend the solution in various ways, and they will ALL cite your work like crazy!"
"Whenever you are proposing a new solution to a problem, think of a brain-dead baseline solution first. For the former, pick an afternoon and concentrate. For the latter, you can do it in the morning, when you are still half-asleep!"
"Dear Internet, Thank you for making it so easy to find size 11N shoes without leaving home! - Love, Big Foot,"
"I think the early bird should get something more appetizing than a worm!"
"Upon meeting Brian Kernighan, someone says, 'Oh, are you the guy from that Kernighan and Ritchie book?' Brian replies, deadpan, 'Yeah, the Kernighan one, not the Ritchie one.'"
Prof1: "I suspect that reading a dissertation in bed will mean 'lights out' before you know it!"
Prof2: "Did you need 'in bed' in that sentence? :-)"
Prof1: "I had long suspected that tenure is a drug. Thanks to Athina for verifying my suspicion - http://www.ece.uci.edu/~athina/aps.pdf"
Prof2: "I don't think the narcotics warning is right." :D
Prof1: "Grading goes more smoothly with a fine Aussie shiraz (the S2 from Marquis Phillips, to be precise). The wine gets an A!"
Prof2: "There are much faster ways to solve this problem: http://www.concurringopinions.com/archives/2006/12/a_guide_to_grad.html"
Prof1: "Caffeine intake is inversely proportional to the time remaining till the paper deadline."
Prof2: "Polyphasic sleep works pretty well: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polyphasic_sleep Unfortunately, it does not always work well for functioning with the rest of the world. :-)"
"To make a start-up grow big very fast, there are two easy ways - steal the code (Huawei) of the established giant (Cisco) in the area, or better still, steal their engineers (Juniper)!"
"Hardware engineers are extremely picky about the restaurants they eat at. They are mortified by 'bugs', in their food, not just their code!"
"Is there anyone who didn't understand what I just explained? Other than me, that is!"
(An MSR guy, not actually prof): "Research in Google? That is an oxymoron!"
IITM Profs:
(Praise for another prof's hand-writing on the board) "Look at these beautiful betas and gammas, I don't feel like erasing the board!"
"Yesterday there was only one guy in the class, I didn't know who he was, he didn't know who I was, and both of us were seeing each other faces!"
"Every day I see a new batch. The batch that came day before yesterday had no similarity what so ever to the eight guys that turned up yesterday, and those guys are no similar to the batch I see today!"
"In the world of computers, if you want to get something you should lose something. Thats why CS also stands for Communist Science!"
"Did you guys understand or not?" When the students sit quietly even then, "Why are you all sitting like Buddhist monks?! At least nod your head folks!"
(While teaching serialization in OS) "A sequential program is like a monkey - hard to debug. A parallel program is a drunken monkey bitten by a scorpion!"
"How can I make it more approximate?"
"There is one other some more stuff is left..."
"In speech, there is no going back, since it is time. There is also no backspace key."
"An unbiased coin will have equal probability of occurrance of all it's faces."
"This is the usual use of Lagrange Multipliers. We use the usual philosophy of using Lagrange Multipliers."
(When proving something...) "Suppose we start with a contradiction..."
(When proving x <= y...) "Assume that x <= y. There is a reason for this assumption, we'll come to this later."
(S is a set of symbols) "In S^n, each s is made up of S x S x S ... n times."
"Huffman is greedy. It forms graphs. A tree is also a graph, without self loops or negative weight edges."
"We will look at all possible paths that are possible."
"He kind of met me and he promised me he'll be coming to class regularly with his parents!"
"I will lose this much stuff if the channel gets erased..."
"It's a completely aside problem, but it's similar in a different context..."
"Will I decide how I decide the symbol."
"Any unit which is more than 1 unit long is a mis-transmission..."
(When contrasting erroneous transmissions to a coin toss) "When I am tossing a coin, it's like how many times I get an error!"
"Average of n numbers converges to their mean..."
(After the lecture) "I've actually referred *hajjar* sources for this!"
more stuff is left..."
"Time is so continuous..."
(When the prof almost fell of the dais) "We're all so great - we slip!"
"By chance if I trip and fall, please help me!"
(Cutting a long proof short) "Do not argue step by step!"
(The prof never says numerator/denominator) "x/(x*y). We can cancel x from upstairs and downstairs."
"I am trying to optimize between theory and problems."
"I write so beautifully that there might be parallax error!"
"You have more pleasures than I have!"
"About the absentees, we crib to the people who are present..."
"Slight parameters are varying for me, so, I might take 10'o clock class."
"People become sensitive very fast. Convergence occurs very fast..."
"If I see a teacher telling, 'Do this, do that...', I will find her mad."
"... for nicer mortals like us ..."
(During a late evening class) "At least some enthu I am showing at my old age!"
"A particle in motion never leaves its trajectory."
"Everybody turn up for the tomorrow's class, there's going to be a surprise test!"
(On probability density functions) "Though it is a probability only, somehow it seems to take values greater than one! That is acceptable. I'll come to it later!"
Explaining the funda of the CS Club) "This is a club - so we can have fun activities like going to a picnic, etc. But it is the CS club - so we should always think of algorithms to reach places faster, etc!"
(Explaining an application of Data Mining) "The results indicate that there is a high correlation between beer buyers and diaper buyers. That doesn't mean one should sell beer and diaper as a combo pack!"
(Some data mining funda) "Larger my size, lesser the depth and its easy to find the spot!"
"What do you know abhout 'sex-fear'? Was 'sex-fear' a nobhalist? Or a poet? Or a dromotist? Or ebherything?"
"Lipids are hydrophobic, but water is hydrophilic."
(On Lovasz and Graph Theory): "Lovasz is a well known name in graph theory. His book is widely used by many. He used to do a lot of good work in this subject." (Turns slightly towards the board, before adding) "But, now he has joined Microsoft."
(Refering to the heat) "See, I am going to melt in a while!"
"O2, which we will must have absolutely..."
"Dharma in Dhermal energy is Dharmodynamics!"
"Let's see what's happening in the atmosphere... photosynthesis is happening..."
"Organisms called herbivores, carnivores, they do the job of consumption."
(A terse statement about the food-chain) "Wood is contained in food!"
"Bcteria can be divided into good and bad bacteria!"
"Venus is a pressure cooker."
"Sleeping is the best thing you can do!"
"There is nothing in this world that cannot wait for 50 minutes!"
(Definition of a plane) "A plane is a three dimensional object of negligible thickness passing through three points."
"Do the test well tomorrow. Everyone should get above class average!"
(Seeing a student coming late to class) "You think this is a ship? That you can come in and go anytime?!"
(Shocked by the attendance sheet full of proxies) "Just 7 of you present here but all 71 are marked present! Oh, I guess each one of you represent your department..."
"If you have any doubts, please don't hesitate to ask the TA. If you ask me, you will only make more mistakes!"
"Why are you sleeping in my class? Do I ever come to your room and sleep?!"
Satyamurthy JEE Classes:
"Nitrogen says - when chhota bachcha Carbon is hybridising, why shouldn't I hybridise?!"
"God said to Nitrogen- thou shall not have 10 electrons!"
"Lone pair becomes a pi bond, pi bond becomes a lone pair."
"Bal Gangadhar Tilak said Swaraj is my birthright! Carbocation said Rearrangement is my birthright!"
"Shorter the bond - stronger the bond. Longer the bond - weaker the bond!"
"F wants electrons; it eats electrons; it gobbles up electrons. It goes about saying, 'I am the most electronegative element! I want electrons!' F can turn nose into nose flouride! Tongue into tongue flouride." Then he points to an unattentive student, Sahil, and says, "Sahil into Sahil flouride! Amar, Akbar or Antony; Ram, Rahim or Robert; Shankar, Salim or Simon, if F comes by, they will bcome Amar Fluoride, Akbar Fluoride and Antony Fluoride; Ram Flouride, Rahim Flouride and Robert Flouride; Shankar Fluoride, Salim Fluoride and Simon Fluoride!"
"Whoseover tried to isolate flourine reached the lotus feet of God!"
"The first borns in each family are always idiosyncratic. The parents are not experienced, and drop them a couple of times. Similarly, the first element in every group is also idiosyncratic!"
(Explaining hyperconjugative resonance) "You like to go and help the next door aunty and not your mother because she has a pretty daughter! But then you find that your elder brother is already there!"
"Every thing in this world is optically active. Except maybe vampires and ghosts! Your hair is optically active, your skin is optically active! Also, every thing has a mirror image. Except maybe vampires and ghosts again!"
"So you think ozone must have a ring structure?! On your birthday! No no no no no, chemistry stands for truth, experimental truth!"
"There is no salvation without solvation!"
"At 2 in the morning, rickshaw-wala Ramaswamy wont get savari! But at 2 in the morning, you can get up and study! Nobody can stop you!"
(Explaining balanced equations) "Al + Cu --> Au + Cl - perfectly balanced equation illaya? Small 'l' and 'u' on the right and the left; big 'C' and 'A' on the right and the left. But will u get gold, gold, gold?! No no no!"
"Did you perform the experiment? Did you shake hands with the molecule?"
(When a student asks how they can memorize so many compound structures) "Useless fellow, you are able to remeber who was Miss Universe and Miss World a decade ago! Why not this?!"
"If you are bored with studying maths, physics and chemistry, try reading physics, chemistry and maths! Or chemistry, maths and physics!"
(Suggesting a way to remember the Periodic table) "You get up in the morning. You fold your hands and say 'Gajananam butha ganadhi sevitham...' Same way, you should also say 'Hydrogen Lithium Sodium Potassium Rubidium Ceasium Francium...'!"
"If you study well, you will go to IIT. Else, you will go to Madha engg college or Pidha engg college..."
"If you want cis-trans configuration, you have to come to chemistry class. If you want tansfiguration, you have to go to Hogwarts school!"
(Pointing to a student's head) "You have millions of neurons here. If you don't use them, you'll all become morons!"
"Potassium chloride and potassium cyanide look the same. If you taste potassium chloride, you will taste it salty. But if you taste potassium cyanide, you will reach the lotus feet of God!"
"It is going to be too tough for you to unlearn these concepts, because they have been taught so well!"
"Yappa, if you can't listen in class, please quit I say! I will give you back your fees, and extra money too!"
(Referring to a student, who attended the class on limits and differentiability but missed the topic in between. He asks with an awesome pun) "Yappa, last row, you only - you attended limits and then you are now attending diffrentiability. Where is the continuity?!"
"Thambi, if you want to clear JEE, 5 hours sleep is a luxury. You have to sleep only for 4 hours!"
"Yappa don't just copy down from the blackboard. In fact even Kasturi(the watchman) can do that.. illiya?!"
(Scolding the PSBB students) "PSBB batch, full of darty rascals... I will dismantle this batch, i say!"
(Lamenting about dropping standards of students in Satyamurthy) "Yappa, there used to be a time when people say, joining Satyamurthy will give you good JEE rank. Nowadays, they say it will give you good AIEEE rank! Very soon, I'm afraid the time will come when they'll say, it will give you good CBSE board marks!"
"If you don't get this, that's all! You miss the bus! You miss the train! You miss the rocket!"
(Explaining the importance of error in titration) "What is the use if you have 5% error! Then you can use buckets and mugs for titration!"
Like I stated before, it is great fun to note down and track these statements by one's teachers :-) I'll continue doing this and put up more of this up here (anonymized of course!) after a few years! Have fun!
PS: Btw, here are some comments (anonymized again!) from the original post. I had deleted the post, rather than edit it, so these comments were gone too.
Blogger Ashish Patro said...
Nice Collection.. Was due to be posted for a long time :)
February 21, 2010 10:02 PM
Blogger A. K. K. said...
@Ashish, thanks :-) have fun!
February 22, 2010 2:43 PM
Blogger kamiya said...
Good job ! :) .. Enjoyed reading it ! :) ..Lolz..
February 22, 2010 2:59 PM
Blogger madthanU said...
WOW ...... thats probably the nicest blog post i enjoyed
February 23, 2010 3:53 PM
Blogger Vijay Chidambaram said...
Nice work da! Good to see work-demon Arun relaxing :P
My favorite was: "Nitrogen says - when chhota bachcha Carbon is hybridising, why shouldn't I hybridise?!""
Lol!
February 26, 2010 8:57 AM
Blogger A. K. K. said...
@Kamiya, Thanu, thanks guys! Glad you enjoyed it :)
@VJ, thanks! But lol, me a work demon huh? That is a nice pj in itself :P
February 26, 2010 12:34 PM
Statutory Disclaimer: The following collection of funny quotes (PJs, bloopers, etc) are 'actual' words spoken by profs that I and my friends have seen over the years. But the intention is not to make fun of profs or put them in trouble, but to recollect and have a laugh at some intentional/unintentional funny statements.
US Profs:
"It is so funny that at the beginning of a class, whenever you turn to the board and turn back, there are more students everytime. But it just reverses towards to end of the class!"
(After explaining a new concept) "Is this clear to everyone? Any questions... what does this term mean... what statement is this... what class is this?!"
(After clarifying an ambiguous concept) "Oh, you guys don't feel happy about it? I feel so good about it!"
"You guys didn't understand it? Ok, let me keep explaining it in different ways till either you understand it or I!"
"All that botanists seem to do is sit and classify things!"
"Biology is only about memorizing, there's no figuring out. I mean, how does one figure out what phylum a plant is in?!"
"Schema matching is still a hard and open problem. If you get a good idea to solve it properly, tell me and we'll stop the course and start a company or something! Then, after we get rich, we can resume the class!"
"Mike Stonebraker once said that schema matching is AI-complete, i.e., it will never be solved by AI folks! And if it is solved, then it was not AI after all!"
"More than a decade ago, when I was at Palo Alto, a prof told me about a couple of bright students who had this new search engine based on their new PageRank algorithm. I thought it was a very nice idea and appreciated them! Darn, I should have instead asked if I could invest in their company right then! Then probably, I wouldn't still be here right now!"
"In a study on web search, it was found that the .edu domain is least frequently updated. So crawlers need not visit these webpages often!"
"There was this professor at Berkeley who forgot to set an exam paper. So he told the class, 'Sorry class, I forgot to set the paper for the exam today. So, here's the deal - those of who are very confident about this course and want an impromptu exam, stay back. Others can leave, I'll just generously give you a B.' Two-thirds of the class left, glad to have got a free B! Then he says to those who remained, 'Great! I'll just give you guys an A!'"
"If one cannot keep up, but cannot fall behind either, then the solution is to do a sloppy job!"
(When a student referred to 2002 as 'way back') "I object to your labeling of 2002 as 'way back'. It makes me feel very old!"
"I've realized that faculty life consists of nothing but emails, deadlines, meetings, and being late for those three!"
"Back when I joined grad school, people preferred primarily two fields - theory, which was considered 'manly', or AI, which was considered 'sexy'! Databases was considered even more boring than accounting!"
"If you want to graduate and leave at the earliest, but your advisor will not let you, then a very good option is to get married! Then, you can blame your 'family problems' for leaving grad school and he will no longer stop you!"
"A main lesson you learn in grad school is to speak very confidently about whatever you want to say, even if you are clueless about it!"
"In research, if you are going to tackle a complicated problem, you shouldn't solve it completely at one go and publish it in one paper. First, publish a good solution for a sub problem of it. Then, you will have lots of people trying to extend the solution in various ways, and they will ALL cite your work like crazy!"
"Whenever you are proposing a new solution to a problem, think of a brain-dead baseline solution first. For the former, pick an afternoon and concentrate. For the latter, you can do it in the morning, when you are still half-asleep!"
"Dear Internet, Thank you for making it so easy to find size 11N shoes without leaving home! - Love, Big Foot,"
"I think the early bird should get something more appetizing than a worm!"
"Upon meeting Brian Kernighan, someone says, 'Oh, are you the guy from that Kernighan and Ritchie book?' Brian replies, deadpan, 'Yeah, the Kernighan one, not the Ritchie one.'"
Prof1: "I suspect that reading a dissertation in bed will mean 'lights out' before you know it!"
Prof2: "Did you need 'in bed' in that sentence? :-)"
Prof1: "I had long suspected that tenure is a drug. Thanks to Athina for verifying my suspicion - http://www.ece.uci.edu/~athina/aps.pdf"
Prof2: "I don't think the narcotics warning is right." :D
Prof1: "Grading goes more smoothly with a fine Aussie shiraz (the S2 from Marquis Phillips, to be precise). The wine gets an A!"
Prof2: "There are much faster ways to solve this problem: http://www.concurringopinions.com/archives/2006/12/a_guide_to_grad.html"
Prof1: "Caffeine intake is inversely proportional to the time remaining till the paper deadline."
Prof2: "Polyphasic sleep works pretty well: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polyphasic_sleep Unfortunately, it does not always work well for functioning with the rest of the world. :-)"
"To make a start-up grow big very fast, there are two easy ways - steal the code (Huawei) of the established giant (Cisco) in the area, or better still, steal their engineers (Juniper)!"
"Hardware engineers are extremely picky about the restaurants they eat at. They are mortified by 'bugs', in their food, not just their code!"
"Is there anyone who didn't understand what I just explained? Other than me, that is!"
(An MSR guy, not actually prof): "Research in Google? That is an oxymoron!"
IITM Profs:
(Praise for another prof's hand-writing on the board) "Look at these beautiful betas and gammas, I don't feel like erasing the board!"
"Yesterday there was only one guy in the class, I didn't know who he was, he didn't know who I was, and both of us were seeing each other faces!"
"Every day I see a new batch. The batch that came day before yesterday had no similarity what so ever to the eight guys that turned up yesterday, and those guys are no similar to the batch I see today!"
"In the world of computers, if you want to get something you should lose something. Thats why CS also stands for Communist Science!"
"Did you guys understand or not?" When the students sit quietly even then, "Why are you all sitting like Buddhist monks?! At least nod your head folks!"
(While teaching serialization in OS) "A sequential program is like a monkey - hard to debug. A parallel program is a drunken monkey bitten by a scorpion!"
"How can I make it more approximate?"
"There is one other some more stuff is left..."
"In speech, there is no going back, since it is time. There is also no backspace key."
"An unbiased coin will have equal probability of occurrance of all it's faces."
"This is the usual use of Lagrange Multipliers. We use the usual philosophy of using Lagrange Multipliers."
(When proving something...) "Suppose we start with a contradiction..."
(When proving x <= y...) "Assume that x <= y. There is a reason for this assumption, we'll come to this later."
(S is a set of symbols) "In S^n, each s is made up of S x S x S ... n times."
"Huffman is greedy. It forms graphs. A tree is also a graph, without self loops or negative weight edges."
"We will look at all possible paths that are possible."
"He kind of met me and he promised me he'll be coming to class regularly with his parents!"
"I will lose this much stuff if the channel gets erased..."
"It's a completely aside problem, but it's similar in a different context..."
"Will I decide how I decide the symbol."
"Any unit which is more than 1 unit long is a mis-transmission..."
(When contrasting erroneous transmissions to a coin toss) "When I am tossing a coin, it's like how many times I get an error!"
"Average of n numbers converges to their mean..."
(After the lecture) "I've actually referred *hajjar* sources for this!"
more stuff is left..."
"Time is so continuous..."
(When the prof almost fell of the dais) "We're all so great - we slip!"
"By chance if I trip and fall, please help me!"
(Cutting a long proof short) "Do not argue step by step!"
(The prof never says numerator/denominator) "x/(x*y). We can cancel x from upstairs and downstairs."
"I am trying to optimize between theory and problems."
"I write so beautifully that there might be parallax error!"
"You have more pleasures than I have!"
"About the absentees, we crib to the people who are present..."
"Slight parameters are varying for me, so, I might take 10'o clock class."
"People become sensitive very fast. Convergence occurs very fast..."
"If I see a teacher telling, 'Do this, do that...', I will find her mad."
"... for nicer mortals like us ..."
(During a late evening class) "At least some enthu I am showing at my old age!"
"A particle in motion never leaves its trajectory."
"Everybody turn up for the tomorrow's class, there's going to be a surprise test!"
(On probability density functions) "Though it is a probability only, somehow it seems to take values greater than one! That is acceptable. I'll come to it later!"
Explaining the funda of the CS Club) "This is a club - so we can have fun activities like going to a picnic, etc. But it is the CS club - so we should always think of algorithms to reach places faster, etc!"
(Explaining an application of Data Mining) "The results indicate that there is a high correlation between beer buyers and diaper buyers. That doesn't mean one should sell beer and diaper as a combo pack!"
(Some data mining funda) "Larger my size, lesser the depth and its easy to find the spot!"
"What do you know abhout 'sex-fear'? Was 'sex-fear' a nobhalist? Or a poet? Or a dromotist? Or ebherything?"
"Lipids are hydrophobic, but water is hydrophilic."
(On Lovasz and Graph Theory): "Lovasz is a well known name in graph theory. His book is widely used by many. He used to do a lot of good work in this subject." (Turns slightly towards the board, before adding) "But, now he has joined Microsoft."
(Refering to the heat) "See, I am going to melt in a while!"
"O2, which we will must have absolutely..."
"Dharma in Dhermal energy is Dharmodynamics!"
"Let's see what's happening in the atmosphere... photosynthesis is happening..."
"Organisms called herbivores, carnivores, they do the job of consumption."
(A terse statement about the food-chain) "Wood is contained in food!"
"Bcteria can be divided into good and bad bacteria!"
"Venus is a pressure cooker."
"Sleeping is the best thing you can do!"
"There is nothing in this world that cannot wait for 50 minutes!"
(Definition of a plane) "A plane is a three dimensional object of negligible thickness passing through three points."
"Do the test well tomorrow. Everyone should get above class average!"
(Seeing a student coming late to class) "You think this is a ship? That you can come in and go anytime?!"
(Shocked by the attendance sheet full of proxies) "Just 7 of you present here but all 71 are marked present! Oh, I guess each one of you represent your department..."
"If you have any doubts, please don't hesitate to ask the TA. If you ask me, you will only make more mistakes!"
"Why are you sleeping in my class? Do I ever come to your room and sleep?!"
Satyamurthy JEE Classes:
"Nitrogen says - when chhota bachcha Carbon is hybridising, why shouldn't I hybridise?!"
"God said to Nitrogen- thou shall not have 10 electrons!"
"Lone pair becomes a pi bond, pi bond becomes a lone pair."
"Bal Gangadhar Tilak said Swaraj is my birthright! Carbocation said Rearrangement is my birthright!"
"Shorter the bond - stronger the bond. Longer the bond - weaker the bond!"
"F wants electrons; it eats electrons; it gobbles up electrons. It goes about saying, 'I am the most electronegative element! I want electrons!' F can turn nose into nose flouride! Tongue into tongue flouride." Then he points to an unattentive student, Sahil, and says, "Sahil into Sahil flouride! Amar, Akbar or Antony; Ram, Rahim or Robert; Shankar, Salim or Simon, if F comes by, they will bcome Amar Fluoride, Akbar Fluoride and Antony Fluoride; Ram Flouride, Rahim Flouride and Robert Flouride; Shankar Fluoride, Salim Fluoride and Simon Fluoride!"
"Whoseover tried to isolate flourine reached the lotus feet of God!"
"The first borns in each family are always idiosyncratic. The parents are not experienced, and drop them a couple of times. Similarly, the first element in every group is also idiosyncratic!"
(Explaining hyperconjugative resonance) "You like to go and help the next door aunty and not your mother because she has a pretty daughter! But then you find that your elder brother is already there!"
"Every thing in this world is optically active. Except maybe vampires and ghosts! Your hair is optically active, your skin is optically active! Also, every thing has a mirror image. Except maybe vampires and ghosts again!"
"So you think ozone must have a ring structure?! On your birthday! No no no no no, chemistry stands for truth, experimental truth!"
"There is no salvation without solvation!"
"At 2 in the morning, rickshaw-wala Ramaswamy wont get savari! But at 2 in the morning, you can get up and study! Nobody can stop you!"
(Explaining balanced equations) "Al + Cu --> Au + Cl - perfectly balanced equation illaya? Small 'l' and 'u' on the right and the left; big 'C' and 'A' on the right and the left. But will u get gold, gold, gold?! No no no!"
"Did you perform the experiment? Did you shake hands with the molecule?"
(When a student asks how they can memorize so many compound structures) "Useless fellow, you are able to remeber who was Miss Universe and Miss World a decade ago! Why not this?!"
"If you are bored with studying maths, physics and chemistry, try reading physics, chemistry and maths! Or chemistry, maths and physics!"
(Suggesting a way to remember the Periodic table) "You get up in the morning. You fold your hands and say 'Gajananam butha ganadhi sevitham...' Same way, you should also say 'Hydrogen Lithium Sodium Potassium Rubidium Ceasium Francium...'!"
"If you study well, you will go to IIT. Else, you will go to Madha engg college or Pidha engg college..."
"If you want cis-trans configuration, you have to come to chemistry class. If you want tansfiguration, you have to go to Hogwarts school!"
(Pointing to a student's head) "You have millions of neurons here. If you don't use them, you'll all become morons!"
"Potassium chloride and potassium cyanide look the same. If you taste potassium chloride, you will taste it salty. But if you taste potassium cyanide, you will reach the lotus feet of God!"
"It is going to be too tough for you to unlearn these concepts, because they have been taught so well!"
"Yappa, if you can't listen in class, please quit I say! I will give you back your fees, and extra money too!"
(Referring to a student, who attended the class on limits and differentiability but missed the topic in between. He asks with an awesome pun) "Yappa, last row, you only - you attended limits and then you are now attending diffrentiability. Where is the continuity?!"
"Thambi, if you want to clear JEE, 5 hours sleep is a luxury. You have to sleep only for 4 hours!"
"Yappa don't just copy down from the blackboard. In fact even Kasturi(the watchman) can do that.. illiya?!"
(Scolding the PSBB students) "PSBB batch, full of darty rascals... I will dismantle this batch, i say!"
(Lamenting about dropping standards of students in Satyamurthy) "Yappa, there used to be a time when people say, joining Satyamurthy will give you good JEE rank. Nowadays, they say it will give you good AIEEE rank! Very soon, I'm afraid the time will come when they'll say, it will give you good CBSE board marks!"
"If you don't get this, that's all! You miss the bus! You miss the train! You miss the rocket!"
(Explaining the importance of error in titration) "What is the use if you have 5% error! Then you can use buckets and mugs for titration!"
Like I stated before, it is great fun to note down and track these statements by one's teachers :-) I'll continue doing this and put up more of this up here (anonymized of course!) after a few years! Have fun!
PS: Btw, here are some comments (anonymized again!) from the original post. I had deleted the post, rather than edit it, so these comments were gone too.
Blogger Ashish Patro said...
Nice Collection.. Was due to be posted for a long time :)
February 21, 2010 10:02 PM
Blogger A. K. K. said...
@Ashish, thanks :-) have fun!
February 22, 2010 2:43 PM
Blogger kamiya said...
Good job ! :) .. Enjoyed reading it ! :) ..Lolz..
February 22, 2010 2:59 PM
Blogger madthanU said...
WOW ...... thats probably the nicest blog post i enjoyed
February 23, 2010 3:53 PM
Blogger Vijay Chidambaram said...
Nice work da! Good to see work-demon Arun relaxing :P
My favorite was: "Nitrogen says - when chhota bachcha Carbon is hybridising, why shouldn't I hybridise?!""
Lol!
February 26, 2010 8:57 AM
Blogger A. K. K. said...
@Kamiya, Thanu, thanks guys! Glad you enjoyed it :)
@VJ, thanks! But lol, me a work demon huh? That is a nice pj in itself :P
February 26, 2010 12:34 PM
Friday, February 26, 2010
Life is a Finite State Automaton
Life (at least mine!) can be characterized as a Finite State Automaton (FSA). For the uninitiated, I quote Wikipedia - "A finite state machine (FSM) or finite state automaton (FSA), or simply a state machine, is a model of behavior composed of a finite number of states, transitions between those states, and actions. It is similar to a "flow graph" where we can inspect the way in which the logic runs when certain conditions are met. A finite state machine is an abstract model of a machine with a primitive (sometimes read-only) internal memory."
Oh yes, I think I have only finite memory and finite processing power up in my head! Also, after giving some thought, I've realized that many situations, circumstances or simply levels of existence can be classified as various finite 'states'! My lifetime passes by staying and transitioning between these states. The transitions depend on external stimuli from the world as well as my current state of mind - hence, more specifically, it is a Mealy machine! This is so because there is an 'output' at/before/after every state transition, and this depends on both the state and the stimulus, which is the 'input'. But of course, not always does the stimulus have to be from outside. It could be from 'within' as well, hence it is an 'intelligent' machine that can acts on its own, not a dumb automaton after all!
Nevertheless, I've managed to identify and isolate some of these states of existence. This may not be comprehensive, but I've given examples to make my point clearer. However, I'm sure the list cannot be infinite, since life itself is finite!
1. Chill State:
Oh yeah, my favorite, totally brain-dead existence! This is when I do totally random and arbit things for fun, timepass, etc. This includes facebook (used to be orkut), movies, youtube (used to be tv), web surfing, going out with friends, 'genning' around etc. This is basically to relax and recuperate! Not only is this the most common, it is also the most difficult to get out of. The amount of mental and physical inertia involved in getting out of this state is incredible!
2. Sleep State:
Not much to say here except that it is good and important to get enough sleep! Sometimes, I get dreams (and nightmares!) but most are usually transient and are forgotten after waking up.
3. Creative State:
This is a special state, when I invent good/funny/arbit quotes (quite common), or think of stuff to write/blog about like philosophical/personal/random stuff (e.g, thinking of writing about this article!), do a drawing/painting (very rare), think of poems/pithy couplets (ultra rare!), etc. This state is quite unpredictable and is also difficult to sustain.
4. Scientific State:
This is another special state, when I think of not-as-fancy-as-creative scientific stuff like solutions to the problems that I explore as part of my research, or abstract mathematical stuff, etc. This state is slightly more predictable than creative state, but is equally difficult to sustain!
5. Writing State:
Okay, it might seem weird to have this as a separate state, but it closely tied to creative and scientific states. My head has to transition to this state in order for me to deliver a good piece of writing, like my blog posts, or papers/reports/slides that I write, etc. In this state, I go 'into' the piece of writing mentally and subsist at that level till it is done. Of course, depending on the nature of the writing, I frequently hop between this state and either the creative or the scientific states. Often, when the piece of writing is too large to finish at one go, I transition to the chill state in between! As expected, this is my current state of mind as I write this article.
6. Knowledge Internalization State:
Quite a fancy name I agree, but this is basically the state of mind when I am reading, listening keenly, observing the world, etc. This could be in various forms like studying the course matter for an exam, reading research papers, learning new technical stuff, reading/watching news, listening to good debates, speaking to knowledgeable people like elders or profs (not all of them!), etc. This also includes be situations like facing failures, loss of something, etc., wherein I learn important lessons of life itself (meta-life!). Obviously, this is a very crucial state to grow as a person. This state is many times a precursor to the scientific and creative states. Currently, I believe this to be your current state of mind as you read this article.
7. Knowledge Dissemination State:
This state is closely related to the writing and knowledge internalization states. Basically, here I disseminate my thoughts to the world, in various forms like talking, arguing, discussing, doing, etc. In fact, the writing state can be viewed as a special case of this, but it is so important in itself, that I think of it as a separate state. Once something is written, if I have to speak about it, then I transition to this state. This also involves analysis and answering questions, facing the world, etc. by digesting and recreating whatever knowledge has been internalized, apart from the output of the scientific and creative states. So this includes activities like answering exams, interviews, etc!
8. Philosophical State:
Despite all knowledge flows and vagaries of reality, there are times when I ponder over stuff that are beyond normal human understanding. This primarily includes thinking and concluding about stuff like, what is the purpose of life, what is God, etc. Often, this is the state that I transition to when I get bored or fed up with the other states! And this leads me back to any those, depending on the stimulus. Sometimes, my existence in this state invites ridicule! This state also involves things like introspection of things that are input to me from the knowledge internalization or other states.
9. Null State:
This is very special state when my mind is completely blank - null! This could be because of various reasons, and in this state I feel nothing, think nothing and do nothing! It is almost as I forget the universe and I don't exist at all - I suppose that sounds shady enough! Transition to this state is mostly involuntary. It includes cases when I spend so much time in the philosophical state to realize the futility of life (!), and then move to this state to spend some time in 'emptiness' in order to recuperate. Or it could be things like a sudden cool scientific discovery of my own (huh?), following which I move to this state momentarily. For the most part, this state is highly transient and unstable, and I eventually move to a stable state.
There are a few other minor states, like Chores State, which includes things like eating, bathing, traveling here and there, etc., especially when I have to apply my mind to them, etc., but they are not particularly interesting on their own. Of course, they become interesting when I transition momentarily to other states, e.g., internalizing observations from the world while traveling, new creative/scientific ideas while bathing (eureka moments!), etc.
Many times, I swing between some of these states so fast that it becomes difficult to ascertain what state exactly I am in, but by and large, my mind would be stationary in one state (most often the chill or sleep states!)
Also, there is the question of 'feelings' like happiness, sorrow, anger, etc. I think these feelings are just 'attributes' of the state of existence, they are not states in themselves. E.g., I could write something in anger or out of happiness, I could be happy or sad when I chill out, etc.
So now, all that remains is for me to draw the state transition diagram. Unfortunately (or fortunately), it so happens that the FSA is so complex (or simple) that I could transition from any state to any other state (kind of like a complete graph)! The labels that go on the edges are highly variant, since they depend on external as well as internal stimuli, and the outputs are also highly variant. I can think and categorize them, but they might end up being separate articles themselves!
Ah finally, we've come to the end of this article. I think I've spent enough time in the creative and the writing states for this. Now I think I shall transition to the chill and the sleep states!
Oh yes, I think I have only finite memory and finite processing power up in my head! Also, after giving some thought, I've realized that many situations, circumstances or simply levels of existence can be classified as various finite 'states'! My lifetime passes by staying and transitioning between these states. The transitions depend on external stimuli from the world as well as my current state of mind - hence, more specifically, it is a Mealy machine! This is so because there is an 'output' at/before/after every state transition, and this depends on both the state and the stimulus, which is the 'input'. But of course, not always does the stimulus have to be from outside. It could be from 'within' as well, hence it is an 'intelligent' machine that can acts on its own, not a dumb automaton after all!
Nevertheless, I've managed to identify and isolate some of these states of existence. This may not be comprehensive, but I've given examples to make my point clearer. However, I'm sure the list cannot be infinite, since life itself is finite!
1. Chill State:
Oh yeah, my favorite, totally brain-dead existence! This is when I do totally random and arbit things for fun, timepass, etc. This includes facebook (used to be orkut), movies, youtube (used to be tv), web surfing, going out with friends, 'genning' around etc. This is basically to relax and recuperate! Not only is this the most common, it is also the most difficult to get out of. The amount of mental and physical inertia involved in getting out of this state is incredible!
2. Sleep State:
Not much to say here except that it is good and important to get enough sleep! Sometimes, I get dreams (and nightmares!) but most are usually transient and are forgotten after waking up.
3. Creative State:
This is a special state, when I invent good/funny/arbit quotes (quite common), or think of stuff to write/blog about like philosophical/personal/random stuff (e.g, thinking of writing about this article!), do a drawing/painting (very rare), think of poems/pithy couplets (ultra rare!), etc. This state is quite unpredictable and is also difficult to sustain.
4. Scientific State:
This is another special state, when I think of not-as-fancy-as-creative scientific stuff like solutions to the problems that I explore as part of my research, or abstract mathematical stuff, etc. This state is slightly more predictable than creative state, but is equally difficult to sustain!
5. Writing State:
Okay, it might seem weird to have this as a separate state, but it closely tied to creative and scientific states. My head has to transition to this state in order for me to deliver a good piece of writing, like my blog posts, or papers/reports/slides that I write, etc. In this state, I go 'into' the piece of writing mentally and subsist at that level till it is done. Of course, depending on the nature of the writing, I frequently hop between this state and either the creative or the scientific states. Often, when the piece of writing is too large to finish at one go, I transition to the chill state in between! As expected, this is my current state of mind as I write this article.
6. Knowledge Internalization State:
Quite a fancy name I agree, but this is basically the state of mind when I am reading, listening keenly, observing the world, etc. This could be in various forms like studying the course matter for an exam, reading research papers, learning new technical stuff, reading/watching news, listening to good debates, speaking to knowledgeable people like elders or profs (not all of them!), etc. This also includes be situations like facing failures, loss of something, etc., wherein I learn important lessons of life itself (meta-life!). Obviously, this is a very crucial state to grow as a person. This state is many times a precursor to the scientific and creative states. Currently, I believe this to be your current state of mind as you read this article.
7. Knowledge Dissemination State:
This state is closely related to the writing and knowledge internalization states. Basically, here I disseminate my thoughts to the world, in various forms like talking, arguing, discussing, doing, etc. In fact, the writing state can be viewed as a special case of this, but it is so important in itself, that I think of it as a separate state. Once something is written, if I have to speak about it, then I transition to this state. This also involves analysis and answering questions, facing the world, etc. by digesting and recreating whatever knowledge has been internalized, apart from the output of the scientific and creative states. So this includes activities like answering exams, interviews, etc!
8. Philosophical State:
Despite all knowledge flows and vagaries of reality, there are times when I ponder over stuff that are beyond normal human understanding. This primarily includes thinking and concluding about stuff like, what is the purpose of life, what is God, etc. Often, this is the state that I transition to when I get bored or fed up with the other states! And this leads me back to any those, depending on the stimulus. Sometimes, my existence in this state invites ridicule! This state also involves things like introspection of things that are input to me from the knowledge internalization or other states.
9. Null State:
This is very special state when my mind is completely blank - null! This could be because of various reasons, and in this state I feel nothing, think nothing and do nothing! It is almost as I forget the universe and I don't exist at all - I suppose that sounds shady enough! Transition to this state is mostly involuntary. It includes cases when I spend so much time in the philosophical state to realize the futility of life (!), and then move to this state to spend some time in 'emptiness' in order to recuperate. Or it could be things like a sudden cool scientific discovery of my own (huh?), following which I move to this state momentarily. For the most part, this state is highly transient and unstable, and I eventually move to a stable state.
There are a few other minor states, like Chores State, which includes things like eating, bathing, traveling here and there, etc., especially when I have to apply my mind to them, etc., but they are not particularly interesting on their own. Of course, they become interesting when I transition momentarily to other states, e.g., internalizing observations from the world while traveling, new creative/scientific ideas while bathing (eureka moments!), etc.
Many times, I swing between some of these states so fast that it becomes difficult to ascertain what state exactly I am in, but by and large, my mind would be stationary in one state (most often the chill or sleep states!)
Also, there is the question of 'feelings' like happiness, sorrow, anger, etc. I think these feelings are just 'attributes' of the state of existence, they are not states in themselves. E.g., I could write something in anger or out of happiness, I could be happy or sad when I chill out, etc.
So now, all that remains is for me to draw the state transition diagram. Unfortunately (or fortunately), it so happens that the FSA is so complex (or simple) that I could transition from any state to any other state (kind of like a complete graph)! The labels that go on the edges are highly variant, since they depend on external as well as internal stimuli, and the outputs are also highly variant. I can think and categorize them, but they might end up being separate articles themselves!
Ah finally, we've come to the end of this article. I think I've spent enough time in the creative and the writing states for this. Now I think I shall transition to the chill and the sleep states!
Monday, February 15, 2010
Achieving Against All Odds
Naga Naresh is one of those incredible people who achieve against all odds, and inspire many others along the way. I've seen him myself and have also seen his story on various posts and news articles. I thought it might be good to share his story through this blog as well:
http://specials.rediff.com/news/2008/jul/28sl1.htm
They say reality is stranger than fiction. I now realize that this is the kind of stuff that classic movies and stories are made of :-)
http://specials.rediff.com/news/2008/jul/28sl1.htm
They say reality is stranger than fiction. I now realize that this is the kind of stuff that classic movies and stories are made of :-)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)